Skip to content

Kubelik conducts Szymanowski, Bartók and Scriabin

Béla Bartók

Herculessaal, Munich · 1956

Instrumentalist
Arthur Grumiaux
Years
1956, 1973, 1978
Conductor
Rafael Kubelík

Listen

Music Preserved · Kubelik Eastern European masterworks

About

These three broadcast performances, spanning more than twenty years, reveal quite different facets of Rafael Kubelík’s musicianship. At first glance, these three works appear to inhabit very different musical worlds, but on closer inspection there is a common thread running through his interpretations: a remarkable sense of structural clarity, an instinctive understanding of orchestral colour and an ability to combine discipline with intense musical expression.

Kubelík was a conductor of enormous versatility, equally at home in the great Austro-German symphonic tradition and the music of his native Czechoslovakia. Yet there was much more to his repertoire than the composers with whom he became most closely associated. These performances of Scriabin, Bartók and Szymanowski offer an opportunity to encounter him in music less frequently represented in his commercial discography.

Scriabin: Symphony No. 3, Op. 43, Le Divin Poème
Completed in 1904, Scriabin’s Third Symphony occupies a pivotal position in the composer’s development. Although still rooted in the late-Romantic tradition, its extraordinary harmonic language and increasingly ecstatic expression begin to point towards the mystical preoccupations of his later works. Cast in three interconnected movements, Luttes, Voluptés and Jeu divin, the symphony traces a progression from struggle, through sensual pleasure, to a final affirmation of spiritual liberation.

In this 1973 performance with the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra, Kubelík’s reading is sonorous and lucid, with tremendous instrumental clarity. It is a remarkably disciplined interpretation, avoiding the ecstatic and voluptuous outpourings that characterise some performances of the work, such as Vasily Petrenko’s with the Oslo Philharmonic (widely regarded as one of the most sensual interpretations) or Kirill Kondrashin’s 1976 account with the Amsterdam Concertgebouw Orchestra.

However, that does not imply a lack of passion, but rather a more controlled and contained approach. The clarity and precision of Kubelík’s interpretation are particularly noticeable in the second movement, Voluptés, where the complex orchestral textures emerge with remarkable definition.

It is an approach that may not satisfy those who look for unrestrained ecstasy in Scriabin, but it reveals another aspect of this extraordinary score: its structural coherence and the discipline that lies beneath its apparently extravagant surface.

Bartók: Violin Concerto No. 2, Sz. 112

The collaboration between Arthur Grumiaux and Rafael Kubelík in this 1956 Paris performance is a particularly fascinating one. Grumiaux, celebrated for the elegance, refinement and purity of his playing, might not immediately suggest the rugged, earthy musical world of Bartók. Yet his account of the Second Violin Concerto is monumental in many ways, delivering an intense and at times surprisingly fierce interpretation of this twentieth-century masterpiece.

Completed in 1938, the concerto belongs to one of Bartók’s most productive periods and combines the rhythmic vitality and melodic inflections of Eastern European folk music with a highly sophisticated musical language. Its formidable demands upon the soloist are not merely technical; the music moves between lyrical introspection, biting rhythmic energy and moments of extraordinary dramatic intensity.

Once again, Kubelík’s precision and clarity come to the fore, this time conducting the Orchestre National de la Radiodiffusion Française. There are some extraordinary moments of ecstasy, even unbridled passion, particularly in the first movement, and the whole performance is vivid and alive.

Grumiaux’s playing has a remarkable intensity, often revealing a grittier, more impassioned side of his musicianship than one might expect from his better-known recordings. His first-movement cadenza is especially compelling, while the climactic closing bars are delivered with an extraordinary degree of verve and passion.

What makes this performance so memorable is the relationship between the soloist and conductor. Kubelík provides a firmly disciplined orchestral framework, yet there is nothing restrained about the resulting performance. On the contrary, the rhythmic precision and clarity seem to intensify the music’s dramatic impact.

Szymanowski: Stabat Mater, Op. 53

Szymanowski’s Stabat Mater, composed in 1926, is in many ways unlike anything else he wrote. The work presents a curious and deeply affecting mixture of early sacred music, Polish religious and folk traditions, and the composer’s own, at times luminous, orchestral writing.

Setting a Polish translation of the medieval Latin sequence, Szymanowski created a work of extraordinary individuality. The sometimes stark, modal writing for the solo voices and chorus stands in striking contrast to the richness and subtlety of the orchestral accompaniment. There are moments that suggest the influence of Stravinsky, others that seem rooted in Polish folk music, while passages of almost archaic simplicity recall the sound world of early sacred music.

Yet these different elements are fused into something unmistakably Szymanowski’s own. The result is a unique blend of styles and influences, at once ancient and modern, austere and richly expressive.
Kubelík seems entirely at home in this musical world. In this 1978 performance with the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, he allows the contrasts within the score to emerge naturally, without exaggerating either its austerity or its more luminous orchestral passages.

It is perhaps the vocal writing that makes the greatest impression. The stark modal lines, whether entrusted to the soloists or the chorus, possess an almost timeless quality, and Kubelík’s sympathetic direction allows their expressive power to speak for itself.

There are wonderful contributions from Soňa Červená and Thomas Stewart, whose performances bring an added intensity and humanity to the work. Here, the conductor’s instinct for clarity serves not simply to reveal the musical structure, but to illuminate the deeply personal and spiritual character of Szymanowski’s music.

It is a compelling portrait of a conductor whose artistry extended far beyond the repertoire for which he is most readily remembered.

Michael Stewart

Contents

Karol Szymanowski (1882 – 1937)

 Stała matka bolejąca (Stabat Mater dolorosa)

Track 1: Stała Matka bolejąca (Stabat mater dolorosa)

Track 2: I któż widział tak cierpiącą (Quis est homo qui non fleret)

Track 3: O, Matko źródło wszechmiłości (O eia mater fons amoris)

Track 4: Spraw niech płaczę z Tobą razem (Fac me tecum pie flere)

Track 5: Panno słodka racz mozołem (Virgo virginum praeclara)

Track 6: Chrystus niech mi będzie grodem (Christe cum sit hinc exire)

Béla Bartók (1881 – 1945)

Violin Concerto No 2

Track 7: 1. Allegro non troppo

Track 8: 2. Andante tranquillo and 3. Allegro molto

Alexander Scriabin (1872 – 1915)

Symphony No 3

Track 9: Introduction: Lento

Track 10:  Luttes: Allegro

Track 11: Voluptés: Lento

Track 12: Jeux divins: Allegro

This recording

The recordings were taken from relays of concerts given by the Orchestre National de la Radiodiffusion Française at the Théâtre des Champs-Elysées, Paris on 23 February 1956 (Bartók Violin Concerto No 2), and by the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra in the Herculessaal, Munich on 1 March 1973 (Scriabin Symphony 3) and 3 June 1978 (Szymanowski Stabat Mater).

The recordings were donated to Music Preserved by Nigel Simeone.

Performers

  • Soprano (Stabat Mater and Les Noces) Evelyn Lear
  • Mezzo-soprano Sonia Červená
  • Baritone Thomas Stewart
  • Bavarian Radio Chorus
  • Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
  • Conductor Rafael Kubelik